Telegraph
(Filed: 06/03/2006)
The House of Lords has inflicted another defeat on the Government by again voting against the introduction of compulsory identity cards.
Peers voted by 277 to 166, a majority of 61, to ensure that the planned introduction of ID cards would guarantee they remained voluntary.
Conservative and Liberal Democrat members of the Lords are worried about provisions in the Identity Card Bill concerning passports.
The Bill will make the issue of new passports conditional on applicants consenting to the inclusion of their fingerprints and other biometric information on the proposed National Identity Register.
The Peers say this will result in the introduction of compulsory ID cards by stealth, and goes against the Government's manifesto pledge on the scheme.
It is the second time Lords have voted to overturn this aspect of the Bill. Their amendments were rejected by the Commons in February.
Liberal Democrat spokesman Lord Phillips of Sudbury, urging the House to once again reject Commons amendments, said it was a thoroughly "ill thought out measure".
He said if the legislation was just about ID cards, many peers would have few, if any misgivings.
"And if it is voluntary the same goes. But what we have here is a Bill that is compulsory, will require 40 million plus citizens to be interviewed for the purposes of taking out an ID card."