vagabond wrote:
I must say I loved it. I don't think the Christmas Specials are the best of Doctor Who any year, but I much preferred this to The Runaway Bride episode, and I'm NOT looking forward to Catherine Tate being the new assistant.
Not sure I enjoyed it so much... kept expecting Bender (the robot, not Barrowman) to make an appearance. The animated Futurama did the story so much better years ago.
But yeah, the xmas specials are a bit of a let down... although Kylie's inclusion could start a trend where we'll see other A'listers putting themselves forward. It might even become the new festive tradition where the nation awaits to see who is this year's Dr Who christmas star - as opposed to awaiting the christmas day Eastender's murder/marrage/disappearance/divorce?
Oh and Miss Tate is going to be a total disaster as the new assistant... are the BBC so hard up they couldn't get someone better? I did quite like Martha Jones, more than Rose even. But a missed opportunity, I feel, was not to cast Thomas Sangster (Tim) from The Family of Blood double episode shown earlier this year.
A character from the past, innocent of the ways of the modern world (and the universe) would have made an interesting contrast to the too worldy Rose and Martha. Plus, we could have had a rest from the silly "I secretly fancy the Dr" story arc the producers seem hung on.
Anyway... I feel my geekness is showing now
